Key Takeaway: The sentiment backdrop is more characterized by a lack of optimism than widespread pessimism. This is in sharp contrast to the experiences of December 2020 and 2019. In those instances, too much holiday cheer led to hangovers in the year that followed (don’t forget, new highs peaked early in 2021 and many areas have been a sideways mess for months now). The current sentiment backdrop is not dissimilar to (though less extreme than) what was experienced in December 2018. Intense selling that month had investors thinking more about the Grinch than Santa Claus. While probably won’t get widespread pessimism this time around without further volatility - but if we do and investors throw in the towel on stocks, it could ultimately help light a fire that leads to early year breadth thrusts like what we experienced in early 2019.
Tactical model argues for caution heading into 2022
Absence of a breadth thrust leaves market looking for energy elsewhere
Liquidity indicator remains supportive but Macro Sentiment and Breadth point to rising risks
There was a story in the WSJ earlier this year about a fund manager who held 900 of his best ideas in his main mutual fund. I saw a model this summer that was made up of nearly 100 individual momentum indicators. Some will use a double-digit number of categories for gauging the market. One more holding, one more indicator, one more lever - it’s as easy as adding one more column in the spreadsheet. If more is better that is great, the question though is at what point is more just too much.
Key Takeaway: Falling bond yields do not inspire confidence. Industry group trends faltering as breadth weakens. Holiday cheer has already turned sour.
After last week’s big jump from Consumer Staples (which held in at #4 this week), it was Utilities making a big move (from #9 to #6) in the rankings. Defensive groups are seeing strength on an absolute basis (more on that in a moment) and that is translating into higher sector rankings and improving conditions at the industry group level.
Real Estate has taken over the top spot in the rankings while cyclical sectors seem to be in a race to the bottom.
Check out this week's Momentum Report, our weekly summation of all the major indexes at a Macro, International, Sector, and Industry Group level.
By analyzing the short-term data in these reports, we get a more tactical view of the current state of markets. This information then helps us put near-term developments into the big picture context and provides insights regarding the structural trends at play.
Let's jump right into it with some of the major takeaways from this week's report:
* ASC Plus Members can access the Momentum Report by clicking the link at the bottom of this post.
The Fed is turning off the liquidity spigot and expects to start raising interest rates next year. There are plenty of historical studies showing the relatively benign impact of the first one or two rate hikes. This cycle, though, will be a bit different than what has been experienced in the past. Historically, the Fed is leading the way with interest rate hikes, moving toward tightening ahead of other global central banks. The muted impact of those initial rate hikes may be partly due to the fact that most central banks have still been accommodative. That is not going to be the case this time around. Nine central banks have raised their interest rates in December alone and by the time the Fed makes its first move, a majority of central banks will likely be tightening.
This week's FOMC meeting has received more than its fair share of attention.
Many are no doubt tired of hearing about it. Some might even mentally paraphrase Thomas Jefferson (in Lin-Manuel Miranda's Hamiliton): Can we get back to prices, please?
Yes, in just a moment.
Yesterday’s headlines announced that the "Fed doubles pace of tapering". Unless you are paying close attention, this probably seems like confusing doublespeak. My friend Joe Kalish (at NDR) put it more succinctly, "Fed Turning Off Liquidity Spigot Sooner."
The Fed will end asset purchases early next year. Based on current expectations, this will be followed by three 25 basis-point interest rate hikes over the remainder of 2022. Powell was clear to emphasize that this pivot, while compelled by higher than expected inflation, has been made possible by improving labor market conditions and strength in the overall economy. That messaging probably helped stocks shake off early weakness yesterday and rally into the close.
Key Takeaway: We have seen some evidence of fear on a shorter-term basis, but still plenty of optimism (and risk) from a longer-term positioning perspective. If we had to sum up the current sentiment backdrop with one data point it would be the AAII survey that shows even split between bears and bulls. Sentiment is neither here nor there and that leaves the door open to a more complete unwinding in optimism at a time of year when the market tends to be filled with holiday cheer. Combine that with increasing headwinds from deteriorating breadth and the trend in earnings revisions turning lower, and the sentiment shifts of 2021 look increasingly incomplete as we move toward 2022.
Sentiment Report Chart of the Week: Earnings Estimates Rolling Over
Key Takeaway: A surge to new highs can leave stocks out of breath. S&P 500 at an all-time high while more NYSE stocks make new lows than new highs. FOMC meeting likely to feature Fed grappling with surging inflation.