"If you board the wrong train, it is no use running along the corridor in the other direction."
German pastor and Nazi resistor Dietrich Bonhoeffer
If the train you are on isn’t going where you want to go, changing locations on the train is of little use. You are still going to wind up in the wrong place.
Sometimes, we believe a train is heading to one place, when it’s actually going somewhere else. Or, after boarding, our view of where we would like to go changes entirely. In either case, we are on the wrong train and need to think about how to get off.
Key Takeaway: Sentiment remains neutral as bulls are on the rebound. Both II and AAII bulls ticked higher last week, and the 5-day put/call ratio dropped to levels indicating complacency. We may have seen the reset in optimism that was needed despite a lack of pessimism suggesting a complete unwind. With neither widespread fear nor clear evidence of sustained breadth improvement, the US is in limbo, challenging previous highs yet not confirming a breaking higher. Our suspicion is that a bout of disappointing news or earnings reports could quickly see nervousness and fear return. That could lead investors to search for better opportunities where sentiment has shifted from optimism to pessimism and breadth is clearly improving (EM, anyone?).
Custom Risk On / Risk Off Ratio breaking out of an 8-month consolidation
Risk On environment favors Emerging Market strength and leadership from Financials
Intermarket analysis shows higher risk assets outperforming across multiple timeframes
Our ‘Risk On’ / ‘Risk Off’ Ratio is getting back in gear after spending most of 2021 going sideways. The ratio first peaked in February and while it visited and revisited that level multiple times as Spring became Summer, which then became Fall, it had not been able to break out until last week. The improvement in the ratio has been fueled by both an up-turn in the ‘Risk On’ index and a more pronounced down-turn in the ‘Risk Off’ index. On the following pages we will take a closer look at what is driving improvement in one and deterioration in the other.
Key Takeaway: Risk On/Risk Off Ratio resolving higher. Commodity strength and bond weakness will have some looking for a new playbook. Breadth set up to lead.
Paying attention to relative strength can help in two ways. It identifies leaders, to whom active investors can tilt toward, and laggards, from whom those same investors can tilt away. Up and down the size scale, Energy and Financials are leaders, while Utilities, Health Care and Consumer Staples are laggards.
At the industry group level, mid-cap groups are seeing improving relative strength, while large-cap groups are seeing their relative strength deteriorate.
In this weekly note, we highlight 10 of the most important charts or themes we're currently seeing in asset classes around the world.
Intermarket Confirmation For Interest Rates
In recent weeks we have witnessed rates break above 1.40% and crude oil achieve its highest level since 2014. One of many missing pieces for the intermarket puzzle is the Copper/Gold ratio, which has been chopping sideways since risk assets peaked back in May. This week, we got an upward resolution, which suggests that base metals will continue to outperform precious metals. But it also suggests we’re entering an environment conducive to higher rates and higher prices for commodities, in general. This is a constructive pattern breakout that supports the global growth and reflation narratives.
Check out this week's Momentum Report, our weekly summation of all the major indexes at a Macro, International, Sector, and Industry Group level.
By analyzing the short-term data in these reports, we get a more tactical view of the current state of markets. This information then helps us put near-term developments into the big picture context and provides insights regarding the structural trends at play.
Let's jump right into it with some of the major takeaways from this week's report:
* ASC Plus Members can access the Momentum Report by clicking the link at the bottom of this post.
If there is something to know about me when it comes to the market, it’s this: When I have a chance to talk about the Value Line Geometric Index, I don’t let it pass. The Value Line index is still a smidge further below its June high than the S&P 500 is from its September high, and the Value Line index has not (yet) re-claimed the lead on a YTD return basis. But over the past month, it has provided some leadership, showing the S&P 500-based indexes the path through the 50-day average. While the cap-weight index (SPY) has changed little over the past month, the equal-weight index (RSP) is up nearly 2% and the Value Line index is up more than 3%. I continue to believe that will be the theme of the fourth quarter.
It's mid-October and things are winding down in the garden.
The greens have perked up as the weather has turned cooler. But attempts to ripen a few final tomatoes as the summer heat fades and the sun spends less and less time above the horizon is like waiting for Godot.
With peak garden season slowing down, I have enough time (and thyme) on my hands to reflect on what went well, and what went awry.
Key Takeaway: Optimism has been unwound, but pessimism remains scarce. We have yet to see a level of fear associated with a complete unwind in sentiment. Still, risks loom overhead with earnings season heating up and the prospect of disappointing news on the horizon. The tailwinds that have accompanied the market for the past 15-months have dissipated. Analysts no longer revise expectations higher, and breadth is weak with more new lows than new highs across the NYSE and Nasdaq combined. Caution could quickly turn into nervousness and fear without a supportive backdrop in the event less than stellar news ushers in price volatility. It’s important to remember that sentiment resets slowly then all at once. We’ve been through the slow part. Now it’s time to see if the market can withstand a potential bout of disappointment.
Analysts and economists no longer chasing reality higher
Downward earnings revisions coming with stocks priced for perfection
Persistent inflation and higher bond yields would be a new experience for many investors
The past year has been one of widespread earnings surprises and large upward revisions. Whether those trends can remain intact as Q3 earnings season gets underway is one of the more important questions the market has to wrestle with right now. Expectations are elevated going into the quarter, but a number of the factors that fueled the earnings strength of the past year are starting to ebb. I have my suspicions that Q3 earnings season will be a repeat of the recent past.