Young investors were swept away in the 2021 speculative bubble and came into 2022 with lofty expectations.
The Numbers: The University of Michigan Survey of Consumers shows that a record 70% of investors in the 18-34 age group came into 2022 expecting that stocks would rise over the course of the year. For the 35-54 age group it was 61% and for those 55+ it was 59%. As of August, all three groups were below 50%, with expectations among younger investors getting more in line with those who have been through more market cycles.
The trend for bonds has been lower for two years, the trend for stocks turned South earlier this year and the trend for commodities rolled over last week.
Why It Matters: If the past pattern holds, the next trend change will be for bonds to turn higher. It’s hard to envision that with so much upward pressure on yields (in US & around the world). But if there is an unloved and under-owned asset, its bonds.
In taking a Deeper Look we look at why it may still be too early to get aggressive on bonds even though that is where we are likely to see leadership emerge.
In this weekly note, we highlight 10 of the most important charts or themes we're currently seeing in asset classes around the world.
Industrials Are Island Hopping
his is a zoomed-in look at the trailing month and a half of price action in the Sector SPDR Industrials ETF XLI. Industrials have the tightest historic correlation to the major averages in the US, so the index provides valuable information for the overall equity market.
Industrials just printed a failed reversal pattern, making for an excellent illustration of the choppy and trendless environment we’re in.
Earlier in the month, XLI launched higher from an island reversal formation. However, there was no follow through and the move immediately stalled. Friday, prices gapped right back into their old range, forming yet another island reversal.
We’re watching the pivot lows around 82.75. If we take those out, we’re likely to get a fresh leg to the downside. This is not just true for Industrials, but the broader market.
Check out this week's Momentum Report, our weekly summation of all the major indexes at a Macro, International, Sector, and Industry Group level.
By analyzing the short-term data in these reports, we get a more tactical view of the current state of markets. This information then helps us put near-term developments into the big picture context and provides insights regarding the structural trends at play.
Let's jump right into it with some of the major takeaways from this week's report:
* ASC Plus Members can access the Momentum Report by clicking the link at the bottom of this post.
A 14% rally in Energy last week (its 3rd best weekly gain in at least the past 30 years) was not enough to keep the long-term in the Energy sector from rolling over last week. This follows the down-turn in the long-term trend in commodities that we discussed last week.
The Details: The longest sustained up-trend in the Energy sector since prior to the Great Financial Crisis has ended. The trend for the Utilities sector also turned lower last week. For the first time since the COVID crisis none of the 11 sectors in the S&P 500 are currently in up-trends.
Many areas of the stock market have undercut their June lows. The largest company (Apple) and an ETF of small-cap stocks (IWM) stand out as exceptions. When we look over 3+ years (rather than just 3+ months) we see that small stocks are back to pre-COVID levels, while Apple has been consolidating its gains.
Why It Matters:
The post-COVID speculative bubble in small-caps has been unwound. For Apple, the work seems hardly to have begun. Apple’s resiliency could become a liability if stocks take another leg lower and investors look again for safe havens to sell. As it stands now, Apple is larger than 5 entire sectors in the S&P 500. Bear markets don’t usually leave anything unscathed.
This All Star Charts +Plus Monthly Playbook breaks down the investment universe into a series of largely binary decisions and tactical calls. Paired with our Weight of the Evidence Dashboard and our Playbook Chartbook, this piece is designed to help active asset allocators follow trends, pursue opportunities, and manage risk.
The S&P 500 just narrowly avoided finishing Q3 with the first back-to-back-to-back 3%+ weekly declines since 2009. It followed that up with the first back-to-back 2.5%+ gains since December 2008 to start Q4. Volatility isn’t showing up in the VIX but it is apparent in the daily and weekly price action.
We sold commodities and bought bonds while tweaking where we get our equity exposure.
The Details: While none of the major asset classes are in up-trends, bonds now hold a relative advantage over stocks and commodities. We adjusted the exposure in the Strategic, Cyclical and Tactical portfolios to reflect these shifts and also to reflect leadership shifts we have seen within equities.
Investor surveys indicate widespread pessimism but asset allocation data (and ETF flows) paint a different picture.
The Numbers: September saw the 5th and 6th times in history that the AAII weekly sentiment survey showed bears above 60%. When bears have growled in the past, exposure to stocks was in the 40s and exposure to cash was only slightly lower. Now, equity exposure is still in the 60s (and above the long-term average) and cash exposure is in the 20s.
The Scales are tipped toward risk and away from opportunity.
A challenging macro backdrop is weighing on the market and unsustained rally attempts have kept Breadth and Trends & Momentum from joining Sentiment as reasons to look for opportunity.
Our Weight of the Evidence Dashboard fills in the details and includes a few high-level charts that we are watching as we head into the 2022 homestretch.
You need to squint to see it, but the long-term trend in the CRB Commodity index fell last week for the first time since the end of 2020.
The Details: This uptrend, the most persistent since 2002-2006, lasted 94 weeks. During that period, the CRB index was up nearly 70%. Over the past two decades, the CRB index has been trending higher 60% of the time and has risen at a 7.3% annual rate during those periods. It has fallen at 5.5% annual rate during the remaining 40% of the time (when the long-term trend has been falling).