From the desk of Steven Strazza @Sstrazza and Ian Culley @Ianculley

In recent weeks, we’ve been diving into individual commodity groups to size up the structural trend and to get a better idea of where we’re likely headed in the new year.

Last week, we highlighted energy contracts and the fact that many are still grappling with overhead supply. And earlier in the month we covered the worst-performing area of the commodity markets - precious metals.

Today, we’re going to turn our attention back to metals and review the base metals group.

Even with the S&P 500 printing record highs, trading ranges and overhead supply stole the show in 2021 and those dominant themes are evident when we look at base metals.

Notice the strong relationship between our equal-weight base metals index and blue-chip international equities in the Global Dow Index $DGT.

From the desk of Steven Strazza @Sstrazza and Ian Culley @Ianculley    

As we approach year-end, we're diving into the individual commodity groups to gauge the status of the primary trends and to get a better idea of where we’re likely headed in 2022. 

Last week, we highlighted precious metals -- by far the worst performers of 2021 with a -10.59% return thus far. We think there's a good chance they'll turn things around next year and start participating.

Today, we’re going to review the other end of the spectrum in terms of performance -- energy! 

While base metals and ags have posted strong gains over the trailing 12-months -- 25.96% and 28.22% respectively -- energy has been the real leader, quietly printing a 46.33% gain despite recent selling pressure.

After crude oil collapsed below zero last year, the entire group had its work cut out. But they’ve covered an amazing amount of ground in a short period of time, and we think they have further to go.

From the desk of Steven Strazza @Sstrazza and Ian Culley @Ianculley

Not unlike the major US equity indexes, the commodity space is still range-bound as we head into year-end.

When we compare the trailing 12-month returns of individual groups, we get a sense of how bifurcated the commodity market has been. Another thing that stands out is just how weak precious metals have been relative to their peers.

While the rest of the asset class has posted solid gains on the year, gold and silver continue to trend lower. If this is truly a commodities supercycle, we’d expect to see some participation from this group. And, considering they’ve been in a downtrend for almost 18-months now as the rest of the space has been working, we’d expect it to happen soon. 

Let’s take a closer look at what’s going on with these shiny rocks.

First, here’s a chart with the trailing 12-month returns of our four major commodity indexes - energy, precious metals, base metals, and ags:

From the desk of Steven Strazza @Sstrazza and Ian Culley @Ianculley

Despite taking a hit in recent weeks, commodities have remained resilient.

Buyers are working to absorb overhead supply at some key levels. We’re seeing this kind of action in commodities across the board -- from industrial and precious metals to energy and even agriculture. We’re seeing prolonged consolidations in some of the most important contracts, such as crude oil, copper, gold, and soybean oil. 

The point is simply that most commodities are correcting through either price or time. Some are digesting gains around former areas of resistance, and others have failed to sustain their breakouts. 

Regardless of where they came from, most commodities are stuck in a range right now. That’s critical information supporting our messy outlook for risk assets.

From the desk of Steven Strazza @Sstrazza and Ian Culley @Ianculley

Risk assets are under pressure.

Failed breakouts and significant retracements have materialized across cyclical areas of the market, including the Russell 2000, the energy and financial sectors, and, of course, commodities.

The energy complex has endured the most severe damage in the commodities realm, with crude oil leading the pack lower. Last Friday’s session was a bruiser, with crude dropping $10 to close out the week.

This kind of volatility can be alarming for any investor.

But when we zoom out--as we like to to at the end of each month--and focus on commodities as a whole, two key takeaways come to the forefront: 

1. The underlying uptrend is still intact.
2.  A period of digestion within the ongoing trend is well deserved. 

Let’s take a look at a couple commodity indexes and try to put the recent action into perspective.

From the desk of Steve Strazza @Sstrazza and Ian Culley @Ianculley

Earlier this month, we discussed our outlook for a post-harvest rally, highlighting corn and soybean oil contracts. 

Here’s what we had to say: 

Cotton and coffee continue to rip. Crude oil and the energy space are grinding higher. Live cattle are breaking out. Even precious metals are starting to catch a bid.

Fast forward to today, and Ags have emerged as the clear leaders over the near term. They’ve been ripping higher while the majority of the commodity space retests critical levels of former resistance and continues to consolidate.

The fact that grains, softs, and livestock are marching higher while their peers are under pressure, tells us this is an area we should focus on for long opportunities. It’s where the relative strength is right now.

From the desk of Steven Strazza @Sstrazza and Ian Culley @Ianculley

We’ve pounded the table on the weakness in energy these past few days, so why stop now? When we find ourselves hammering the same topic time and again, there’s usually a very good reason.

As far as energy goes, there’s been a lot of damage done to the space this week.

Breadth fell off a cliff and was not supporting the new highs for energy stocks.

The relative trends have gotten clobbered, as energy has been among the worst-performing sectors over the near term.

And, just today, we’re seeing failed breakouts in energy sector ETFs across the board.

Since we’ve already written about these themes, let’s dive in and see what energy futures themselves have to say about the situation.

Are futures resilient despite these bearish developments? 

Or are there cautionary signs in the commodities market that are confirming the weakness in the stock market?

Let’s find out.

First up is crude oil:

From the desk of Steven Strazza @Sstrazza and Ian Culley @Ianculley

Commodities are streaking higher, providing plenty of alpha across the entire space to anyone who can pry their eyes away from their altcoin charts.

Cotton and coffee continue to rip. Crude oil and the energy space are grinding higher. Live cattle are breaking out. Even precious metals are starting to catch a bid.

But what about the grain market? Last week, we pointed out that our Minneapolis Wheat position had hit our target and that it was time to feed the ducks.

Today, we’re going to highlight a couple of grain contracts we want to keep on our radar for buying opportunities in the coming weeks and months.

Let’s dive in!

First up is the March 2022 corn contract:

From the desk of Steven Strazza @Sstrazza and Ian Culley @Ianculley

The best opportunities are the ones with the most clearly defined risk characteristics and most favorable risk/rewards.  

This summer, Minneapolis Spring Wheat was offering us a trade set-up with both these qualities. Price had just resolved higher from a near decade-long base and was trading at its highest level in 8 years. We were buying the breakout.

Fast forward to today and our initial profit target has been met and we’re locking in gains.

In today’s post, we’ll take a step back, review our trade, pinpoint current levels of interest, and discuss how we’re managing the position moving forward.

First, let’s look at the weekly chart of Minneapolis Wheat futures:

From the desk of Steven Strazza @Sstrazza and Ian Culley @IanCulley      

Procyclical commodities have attracted all the attention this year as inflation and rising rates have driven prices considerably higher.

But, as we pointed out last week, many of these contracts -- Brent crude, natural gas, copper -- are running into areas of overhead supply or are already in the process of correcting.

With that as our backdrop, let’s switch gears and focus on an area of the commodity space we haven’t talked about in months.

That’s right... precious metals!

While we’re seeing many leading commodities pause at logical levels of resistance, gold and silver have finally stopped going down and are rebounding off support. Despite trending lower since last summer, they're still holding above the lower bounds of their trading ranges. We think this basket of shiny rocks is ripe for review.

Let’s take a look around the precious metals complex and see what’s new.

First, we have a chart of gold futures:

From the desk of Steve Strazza @Sstrazza and Ian Culley @Ianculley

It’s been impossible to ignore the strength in commodities this year.

The CRB Index is up more than 50% over the trailing 52 weeks. During this same period, the S&P 500 is up 32%, and bonds ($TLT) are down more than 8%.

Commodities are the clear leaders.

With breakouts from some of the most commonly observed contracts -- crude oil, copper, and natural gas -- more investors are coming around to the idea that commodities are a viable asset class.

Now that the buzz surrounding this once-forgotten corner of the market is growing, we’re seeing many commodities run into overhead supply zones. We think it would make sense for these contracts to consolidate here. Following such explosive moves off last year’s lows, some sideways action at resistance would be normal behavior.

Let’s look at a few charts that are at logical levels to digest gains.

First up is natural gas futures:

From the desk of Steve Strazza @Sstrazza and Ian Culley @Ianculley

Copper was a critical piece missing from the intermarket puzzle heading into the fourth quarter.

Just last week, copper was testing year-to-date lows and looking vulnerable for a downside break. Meanwhile, energy futures and interest rates were rising, and cyclical and value stocks were getting back in gear.

The mixed signals were impossible to ignore. It’s not likely that the recent breakouts in crude oil and the US 10-year yield would hold in an environment where copper is breaking down.

Dr. Copper is a great leading economic indicator and critical to the global growth narrative. Let’s see what it’s saying.

Here are two ways we were looking at the copper chart: