Key Takeaway: Indexes chopping higher, breadth chopping lower. Commodities leading the pack in 2021. Bonds not fearing inflation.
Health Care made a new high last week and that helped fuel its rise in our relative strength rankings (up to the fourth spot and into the leadership group). Energy and Materials also ticked higher in the rankings, while Consumer Discretionary fell three spots.
Despite an overall theme of large-cap strength, the industry group heat map shows deteriorating conditions across sizes for the Energy and Banks groups.
Key takeaway: Optimism most likely peaked earlier this year, as options activity and equity exposure have continued to trend lower in recent months. Yet, our sentiment indicators show no signs of fear. Of course, it’s hard to imagine an environment plagued by fear when the S&P 500 and Nasdaq push to new highs. However, when we look beneath the surface new highs contract while new lows expand. It seems each day a new bearish divergence in breadth emerges, adding to the fragility and deterioration of an already shaky foundation. Without a supportive backdrop, a price correction or volatility event could lead to a meaningful unwind in sentiment.
Key Takeaway: Indexes at new highs as new high list contracts and new lows expand. Real bond yields drop to their lowest level on record. Prices are rising as the path for growth becomes more uneven.
Communication Services and Real Estate swapped places near the top of our relative strength rankings for the S&P 500. While Real Estate strength persists through the equal-weight version of the rankings and down the market cap scale, Communication Services relative strength appears to be more selective.
Our industry group heat map reflects recent strength among large-cap groups and relative weakness from the mid-cap and small-cap areas of the market.
The S&P 500 fell 1.5% on Monday and rebounded with a 1.5% gain on Tuesday. These were the 31st and 32nd daily moves of 1% or more so far in 2021. At this point last year, we had experienced 72 daily swings of 1% or more, the most we had seen by July in at least two decades. While 2021 has been a drop off from last year’s torrid pace, it’s nothing compared to what was seen in 2017 (which had just 4 moves of 1% in either direction at this point, and finished the year with just 8). What is amazing about 2021 is how closely it has matched the median experience of the past 20+ years. So far this has been a year that is remarkable in its unremarkableness.
Hello, this is the nurse from camp. Your son had an accident. He's fine but I need to talk to you…
I quickly called back to get the details. I was on the road just a few minutes later, making a nighttime trip to a rural emergency room 100 miles away. As it turns out, my son suffered a broken arm during a relatively run-of-the-mill game of chase that involved jumping across a small ditch and not quite sticking the landing. He was doing what we sent him to camp to do.
A couple of hours alone in the car gave me plenty of time to think about all types of risks and how they are unevenly distributed across both space and time. Accidents can really happen anywhere. Still, we have nurses at summer camps, not in our living rooms. Broken arms and other more minor injuries are more likely at the former than the later.
Breadth downgraded to neutral as trends in the US and globally weaken
Absence of breadth thrust regime weighs on a market struggling for direction
Reducing equity exposure in Cyclical and Tactical Opportunity portfolios
The divergences between what has been seen in the popular averages and what is happening beneath the surface have become significant enough that we have moved breadth to neutral in our weight of the evidence framework. This leaves the scales tilted away from opportunity and toward risk.
The most recent breadth thrust regime expired in early June and since then the percentage of global markets trading above their 50-day averages has fallen from the upper 80’s to now just 20%. One-third of the markets are not even above their 200-day averages. US industry group trends have also faltered. The percentage trading above their 10-week averages is breaking down while the percentage making new 13-week lows is breaking out.
Key takeaway: A diminishing appetite for risk combined with deteriorating breadth creates a backdrop conducive to equity indexes catching down to the weakness that has been on display beneath the surface. While bulls remain elevated overall, that could change very quickly as the stage is set for a complete sentiment unwind. Optimism has already begun to edge lower, with AAII bulls dropping to their lowest level since October. Any major signs of adversity could rock the optimistic outlook of a market that has gone relatively unchallenged for the last year.
Sentiment Report Chart of the Week: Risk Off Resolution
Key Takeaway: Despite being dismissed, bad breadth getting worse not better. Defensive groups asserting leadership as risk off trades gain strength. Indexes catching down rather than breadth getting back in gear.
Defensive sectors are perking up on an absolute and relative basis. Utilities, Consumer Staples and Real Estate were all positive last week (Staples even made a new high) and they occupy the top three spots in our short-term relative strength rankings. Staples and Utilities are still longer-term relative strength laggards.
Real Estate remains the top-ranked sector (and is an industry group leader) across the size spectrum.
A recurring theme when it has come to market breadth is that while it has not been keeping pace with the indexes, it has not been breaking down. That is starting to change. Net new highs have turned negative on a 21-day and 63-day basis as divergences are starting to look more like meaningful deterioration. If they turn negative on a 52-week basis (shown below) it would suggest a more significant breakdown in breadth and a building of downside risks in the indexes.