This All Star Charts +Plus Monthly Playbook breaks down the investment universe into a series of largely binary decisions and tactical calls. Paired with our Weight of the Evidence Dashboard, this piece is designed to help active asset allocators follow trends, pursue opportunities, and manage risk.
Key Takeaway: There’s nothing more bullish than new all-time highs, and there was plenty to go around as we reviewed our monthly charts over the weekend. It’s no wonder that optimism is resurfacing as stocks indexes up and down the cap-scale push to new records. Whether current sentiment will develop into the type of risk-seeking fervor that brought us into the year is unseen. But bulls continue to rise, and interestingly so do the bears. The AAII and II bears ticked higher last week, with II bears reaching levels not seen since May of last year. The backdrop is turning to optimism, but there's still enough pessimism among investors to keep sentiment off of the risk side of the scale.
Sentiment Report Chart of the Week: Equity Love Affair Undiminished
We’ve made some changes to our ASC+Plus Dynamic Portfolios.
With the weight of the evidence turning more bullish, we have increased our equity exposure in the cyclical and tactical opportunity portfolios.
Within these portfolios we have also moved away from equity areas that are struggling to participate in the rally and re-focused exposure on areas that are experiencing upside momentum.
Key Takeaway: Index strength fueled by new found momentum. New highs lists are expanding, but not very rapidly. Persistent inflation, sputtering growth are a headache for the Fed.
Consumer Discretionary has been the top-performing large-cap sector on a short-term basis and was one of only two large-cap sectors to make new highs last week (Information Technology was the other). The sector’s relative strength at the large-cap level is not echoed among mid and small-caps, but it is still fairly broad-based (it’s equal-weight ranking matches its cap-weight ranking).
Energy and Financials have lagged on a short-term basis, but remain at the top of our relative strength rankings across size levels.
Plenty of time is wasted and much virtual ink is spilled pulling apart and putting back together various pronouncements by the Federal Reserve and other central banks. With an FOMC meeting on tap, this coming week will likely be more of the same. Rather than focus on what central bankers are saying, it might be more productive to watch what they’re doing. The average central bank (Fed, ECB, BoJ, PBoC) balance sheet has expanded by 10x over the past 20 years (that’s a 25% increase per annum). There is no realistic expectation that balance sheets will contract any time soon. But the pace of expansion is likely to slow (the Fed is expected to announce a timetable for a tapering of its balance sheet expansion this coming week), and interest rates around the world are on the rise. All of the net gains for global equities over the past 30-plus years have come when a majority of central banks have been in easing mode. Currently, just under 60% of central banks are still easing. But, as inflation remains persistent, we expect the number to fall and liquidity headwinds to rise.
"We make our decisions, and then our decisions make us."
I came across that quote in a book I was reading this week (no apologies here -- I read books -- that's what I do).
That prompted me to think about how it was this time last year that I had some decisions to make about what was next in my professional journey. JC and I talked about my joining the All Star Charts team. I (we) made the decision to do just that -- and while the impacts of that decision continue to unfold, I've not regretted it for a moment. And knowing what I know now, that decision seems more obvious than it did when I made it a year ago.
It's not just the active decisions that form us. Where we pay attention matters as well. The 18th century poet William Blake was ahead of his time when he observed how "we become what we behold."
Key Takeaway: There are plenty of adages to remind us that evidence of optimism re-emerging as stocks rally is neither surprising nor necessarily harmful to the health of the rally. When optimism gets overly excessive and begins to retreat we need to pay more attention to the risk side of the equation. What really caught our attention this week was that the imbalance in sentiment expressed by advisory services (Investors Intelligence) and individual investors (AAII) has been resolved. In mid-September, the AAII survey showed 22% bulls and 39% bears while the II survey had 50% bulls and 22% bears. Both surveys now show bulls in the 40’s and bears in the 20’s. Our sentiment chart of the week shows that when we’ve seen this degree of agreement between these surveys in the past, stocks have tended to do pretty well.
China weakness has meant moving away from EEM for Emerging Market Exposure
New highs from Taiwan could point to improving trends for China and EEM
Canada benefitting from exposure to Energy & Financials
Emerging markets have been dealing with the opposite problem that we have discussed in the US. In the US, mega-cap strength has supported the indexes as conditions beneath the surface struggled. In Emerging Markets, mega-cap weakness (China accounts for nearly 22% of EEM) has weighed on the indexes as conditions beneath the surface improved. The goal of this piece is to help discuss how we will know if and when that condition changes.
Given the struggle at the top of the index, we have been utilizing India, Russia, and Saudi Arabia (which together account for 19% of EEM) for Emerging Market exposure. All three of these (as well as FM, Frontier Markets) have made frequent appearances on our new high lists.
Key Takeaway: Mid-caps lead the way as new highs lists expand. Breadth heading in a positive direction but still has work to do. Market rewarding stocks that beat earnings expectations, punishing those that miss.
The Energy and Financials sectors continue to be areas of strength on both a relative and absolute basis. They are the top ranked sectors in our relative strength work and finished last week at news highs.
Real Estate has rebounded in relative strength and is in the third spot overall. At the small-cap and mid-cap level, Real Estate finished at new highs last week.
Consumer Staples, Utilities, and Health Care remain the weakest sectors.
I'm sorry that I had to miss yesterday's Town Hall.
I had a great slide deck prepared (ASC+Plus subscribers can click below for access) and was excited to walk through it with everyone. We are seeing a breakout in our risk on / risk off ratio, continued improvement in sector-level trends, and evidence that sentiment in Emerging Markets looks pretty washed out. While there may be opportunities for following strength and rotating away from US equity exposure, Germany (which is at a 17+ year low versus the S&P 500) is not one of them. I'm sure we will have a chance to talk through many of these things in the days ahead.
As some of you know by now, rather than spending the morning and early-afternoon getting ready for our Town Hall conversation, I was saying a final good-bye to the gentlest of spirits and an ever-faithful friend. Our family dog, Banjo, had a health emergency from which the vet told us there was no reasonable chance of recovery.