From the desk of Steve Strazza @Sstrazza and Alfonso Depablos @AlfCharts
We held our October Monthly Strategy Session Monday night. Premium Members can access and rewatch it here.
Non-members can get a quick recap of the call simply by reading this post each month.
By focusing on long-term, monthly charts, the idea is to take a step back and put things into the context of their structural trends. This is easily one of our most valuable exercises as it forces us to put aside the day-to-day noise and simply examine markets from a “big-picture” point of view.
With that as our backdrop, let’s dive right in and discuss three of the most important charts and/or themes from this month’s call.
One of our favorite anecdotal indicators is the classic magazine cover.
Journalists do a tremendous job of aggregating consumer and investor sentiment.
By the time these magazines and other features take time to plan, develop, and eventually publish their covers, they're always going to be late to the party.
That time delay often presents a prime opportunity for investors.
Similarly, ETF providers also give us a wealth of sentiment information, particularly when it comes to ETF launches and de-listings.
ETF providers have a hilarious track record of launching funds at the complete worst time while de-listing them right before things get going.
A classic example is the coal ETF that got de-listed right before the epic bull market in coal stocks just began.
In crypto, we have yet another insightful indicator, one I like to call the "FTX indicator."
People get so angry when I tell them that Energy stocks haven't even broken out yet...
The historic outperformance in Energy over the past 2 years is just the pregame.
The real party hasn't even gotten started.
The DJ is still setting up....
We haven't even mixed the jungle juice.
Take a look at the Energy Sector Index still stuck below those 2008 highs. And its largest component Exxon Mobil (23.7% weighting) below those same levels:
We sold commodities and bought bonds while tweaking where we get our equity exposure.
The Details: While none of the major asset classes are in up-trends, bonds now hold a relative advantage over stocks and commodities. We adjusted the exposure in the Strategic, Cyclical and Tactical portfolios to reflect these shifts and also to reflect leadership shifts we have seen within equities.
Investor surveys indicate widespread pessimism but asset allocation data (and ETF flows) paint a different picture.
The Numbers: September saw the 5th and 6th times in history that the AAII weekly sentiment survey showed bears above 60%. When bears have growled in the past, exposure to stocks was in the 40s and exposure to cash was only slightly lower. Now, equity exposure is still in the 60s (and above the long-term average) and cash exposure is in the 20s.
Why It Matters: Sentiment extremes can be valuable contrarian indicators, but this can’t work as well if sentiment is divorced from positioning. If cash has not been accumulated as investors turn bearish, there is little to put to work when the crowd’s mood turns more hopeful.
In this week’s Sentiment Report we see plenty of evidence that investors are feeling pessimistic. We could be more constructive if those feelings had already been accompanied by...
Even though stocks have broadly advanced on the first two trading days of October and Q4, today's market action reminds players that stocks are still risky here and the options market continues to price in this fear in the form of higher than normal options premiums.
As such, the odds favor net premium sellers in these conditions -- so that's what we're on the hunt for.
Ideal setups are ones in which a nearby support level has revealed itself so we can lean against it for risk management purposes.
One such setup can be found in Brookfield Asset Management, $BAM: