Skip to main content

Gold: Opportunity Cost or Downside Risk?

September 18, 2023

From the Desk of Ian Culley @IanCulley

Precious metals represent an opportunity cost.

The entire complex – gold, silver, platinum, and palladium – has gone nowhere for the past few years.

Yet I can’t overlook the resilience of gold and silver as interest rates and the US dollar rise – two significant headwinds for these shiny rocks. 

Perhaps they deserve the benefit of the doubt.  

I believe they do.

But extending these lackluster metals with a favorable outlook does not equate to taking a long position.

It’s far from it.

Price must prove buying precious metals offers a rewarding proposition.

The following two intermarket ratios will undoubtedly rise if and when it does.

I covered these ratio charts in late July as they neared key inflection points or critical former support levels.

Fast-forward to today, and both are bouncing higher after posting fresh lows.

Check out the Gold Miners ETF $GDX versus the S&P 500 ETF $SPY:

Now is the time, and the shelf of former lows marks the place for gold miners to assume a leadership role.

That was the message in late July.

And it’s the same message today – with one key difference: GDX shows signs of life, or relative strength.

Mining stocks must outperform the broader market to create sufficient bullish conviction. Otherwise, any additional attempt at new all-time highs for gold will fail. 

Silver Miners $SIL will also outperform Silver $SLV if a true risk-on event hits precious metals:

The SIL/SLV ratio has stopped falling, reclaiming its 2016 low last week.

These risk-on ratios have plenty of work to do. But they have to start somewhere.

Gold has dazzled with moments of brilliance, retesting former highs earlier this spring. 

A new all-time high will come. But it won’t happen until these risk-on ratios rise.

In fact, gold will not only represent an opportunity cost but will signify downside risk if and when GDX-to-SPY and SIL-to-SLV break down to fresh decade-lows.

I’ll continue to track these critical ratios for insight into gold’s next move.

Stay tuned!

Click here to watch this week’s Gold Rush Video:

Remote video URL

Let us know what you think. We love hearing from you.

Thanks for reading.

And be sure to download this week’s Precious Metals Report below!

Click here to download the Precious Metals Report chartbook.

Allstarcharts Team

Filed Under